Skip to main content
Debunk · Nutrition Facts

Seed oils aren't poisoning anyone, and they don't explain why Americans are heavier than in the 1970s


Serving size
1 Debunk
Published
November 1, 2026

Misleading

The claim, as packaged:
This switch was made because saturated animal fats were thought to be unhealthy, but we have since discovered that seed oils are one of the driving causes of the obesity epidemic. Interestingly enough, this began to drastically rise around the same time fast food restaurants switched from beef tallow to seed oils in their fryers. … Americans should have every right to eat out at a restaurant without being unknowingly poisoned by heavily subsidized seed oils.
Source: Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) on X, 21 October 2024 ("Make Frying Oil Tallow Again")

The claim

The popular version is a meme: people in the 1970s were thin, people now are not, and seed oils are the main reason. We could not trace that exact wording to a named person. The best-known primary statement of the idea is a post on X by Robert F. Kennedy Jr from 21 October 2024, which has been viewed about 10 million times:

This switch was made because saturated animal fats were thought to be unhealthy, but we have since discovered that seed oils are one of the driving causes of the obesity epidemic. Interestingly enough, this began to drastically rise around the same time fast food restaurants switched from beef tallow to seed oils in their fryers. … Americans should have every right to eat out at a restaurant without being unknowingly poisoned by heavily subsidized seed oils.

Kennedy's own words are "one of the driving causes" and "poisoned". He did not say "main reason", and we won't attribute that to him. A Guardian column by the epidemiologist Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz says Kennedy "has called them 'toxic'", but it gives no source for that, and we could not find a dated quote.

The claim is back in circulation this week. The Guardian column was shared widely on Bluesky, and a viral reply to the "70s" meme offered a rival single cause: "Because of the cigarettes."

Taken apart, the claim makes five assertions:

  1. Americans are much heavier than they were in the 1970s.
  2. Americans eat far more seed oil than they used to.
  3. The weight gain began when seed oils replaced tallow.
  4. Seed oils cause weight gain beyond their calories.
  5. Seed oils are toxic.

The first two are true. The last three are not supported.

What the claim gets right

Americans really are much heavier. The CDC's measured height-and-weight surveys show age-adjusted obesity among adults aged 20 to 74 rising like this:

Survey years Obesity (BMI ≥30)
1960–62 13.4%
1971–74 14.5%
1976–80 15.0%
1988–94 23.2%
2017–18 42.8%
2021–23 40.8%

That is roughly a tripling since the 1970s. The most recent wave used a new sample design after the COVID-19 pause, so the small dip at the end should not be read as a trend.

Seed-oil consumption really did explode. A historical reconstruction by Blasbalg and colleagues estimates that soybean oil available per person rose from 0.009 kg in 1909 to 11.64 kg in 1999, "a 1163-fold increase". By 1999 soybean oil supplied an estimated 7.38% of energy. That figure comes from commodity "disappearance" data, which is a model, not a measurement of what anyone ate. The authors say so themselves: such data "typically overestimate food consumption by ≥25%."

Claims that seed oils make up a round share of American calories, such as 20%, circulate widely. We could not trace any such figure to a primary source, so we have not used one.

Fats and oils are the biggest single part of the extra calories. This is the claimant's strongest point. The USDA's Economic Research Service estimated that the food supply grew from 2,234 calories per person per day in 1970 to 2,757 in 2003. "Added fats and oils accounted for an extra 216 calories per person per day—or 42 percent of the 523-calorie increase." Grains added 188 calories and sugars 76.

Two caveats apply. These are supply estimates, not measured intake. And the ERS figure covers all added fats and oils, not seed oils alone; it does not split out soybean oil from shortening, butter or lard. Even so, oil is a real part of why Americans eat more than they did in 1970.

The timing doesn't fit

Kennedy dates the obesity epidemic to the period when fast-food chains moved their fryers from tallow to seed oil. He says McDonald's made that switch in 1990. The CDC table shows obesity had already jumped from 15.0% in 1976–80 to 23.2% in 1988–94. A 1995 NEJM analysis dates the rise in overweight to 1978–1990. The epidemic was well under way before the fryer switch.

The timing is also wrong in the other direction. Blasbalg's data show that most of the growth in soybean oil came after 1946, with the steepest rise after the American Heart Association's 1961 advice on dietary fat. Through the 1960s and 1970s, while that rise was happening, obesity stayed flat at 13–15%. If seed oil were a potent cause of obesity on its own, the curves should have moved together. They didn't.

Calorie for calorie, seed oil doesn't fatten more

The claim needs seed oils to do something beyond adding calories. The trials we reviewed do not show that.

In the LIPOGAIN trial, 39 young, normal-weight adults were overfed muffins made with either sunflower oil or palm oil, a saturated fat, for seven weeks. "Both groups gained similar weight." The palm-oil group gained more liver fat and twice as much visceral fat, the fat around the organs. This was a small, short overfeeding study, the comparison fat was palm oil rather than tallow, and it does not show that seed oils are slimming. It does show that, at equal calories, sunflower oil was not the more fattening fat.

A 2018 Cochrane review of randomised trials found that increasing omega-6 fats "probably has little or no effect on adiposity". That conclusion rests on a single trial of 371 people, which is thin. It is still the opposite of what the claim predicts.

What does make people overeat? In an inpatient trial by Hall and colleagues, 20 adults ate about 508 more calories a day on an ultra-processed diet than on an unprocessed one. The two diets were matched for fat, sugar and other nutrients, and people ate as much as they wanted. Participants gained 0.9 kg in two weeks on the ultra-processed diet and lost 0.9 kg on the unprocessed one. The trial was small and short, and it did not test seed oils. Still, it points at the form food comes in, not at a single ingredient. Much of the seed oil Americans eat comes in fried and ultra-processed food, which is where the claimant is pointing at something real, for the wrong reason.

"Poisoned" is not supported, but the case for benefit is weaker than you may have heard

A pooled analysis of 30 cohorts, with 68,659 participants, found that people with higher blood levels of linoleic acid, the main omega-6 fat in seed oils, had lower rates of cardiovascular disease and cardiovascular death. That is an association from a biomarker measured once, so it cannot prove causation. Two of its authors reported research funding from Unilever. One of them, Jason Wu, is also the expert the Guardian quotes. Even so, it is hard to square with a poison.

The mainstream case has gaps too. In a re-analysis of the Minnesota Coronary Experiment, a 1968–73 trial that replaced saturated fat with corn oil, cholesterol fell but there was "no mortality benefit". The authors concluded that incomplete publication had led to "overestimation of the benefits of replacing saturated fat with vegetable oils." That trial is now decades old and its data are incomplete, and the control diet contained substantial trans fat. Cochrane likewise found that the "benefits of omega-6 fats remain to be proven." So the Guardian column goes too far when it calls seed oils "perfectly healthy" and the concerns "largely disproven". It also says animal fats "contain" LDL cholesterol, which is wrong. Saturated fat raises LDL in the blood; food doesn't contain it. But "benefit unproven" is a long way from "toxic". Neither trial measured body weight.

Claims that seed oils cause inflammation or form harmful compounds when heated are covered in our earlier seed-oil debunk, which we graded D. We did not reassess that evidence here.

Kennedy, now Health Secretary, has himself stepped back from the claim. In a January 2026 interview with USA TODAY, he said: "I have personal concerns … But the critique of seed oils has not been scientifically validated."

Cigarettes aren't the answer either

The rival answer from Bluesky, that people were thin in the 1970s because they smoked, deserves the same test. Smoking does suppress weight, and quitting adds some. The 1995 NEJM analysis found quitting added 4.4–5.0 kg over ten years. It attributed about a quarter of the 1978–90 rise in overweight among men, and about a sixth among women, to people quitting smoking. A 2007 follow-up estimated that if smoking rates had stayed at early-1970s levels, obesity in 1999–2002 would have been 22.5% instead of 23.9%: "a difference of only 1.4 percentage points." Smoking is a real but minor part of the story.

What we did not assess

The claim says people are "sicker" as well as heavier. We did not examine trends in diabetes, cancer or other chronic disease since the 1970s, or any role seed oils might play in them. The outcome evidence here covers only body weight and cardiovascular disease. We also did not check Kennedy's statements that the oils are "heavily subsidized" or that McDonald's used tallow from 1940.

Why D and not E

The claim takes real trends, an obesity epidemic and a huge rise in seed oil, and attaches the wrong cause to them. Added fats and oils really are the largest single contributor to the extra calories in the American food supply since 1970. In that narrow sense, oil is part of why Americans weigh more. That real finding is what keeps this from being an E.

What the evidence contradicts is the explanation. The rise in seed oil came decades before the rise in obesity. Obesity was already climbing before the 1990 fryer switch. At equal calories, sunflower oil fattened no more than palm oil. And the largest observational evidence links higher omega-6 levels with less heart disease, not more. Swapping fryer oil for tallow changes the type of fat, not the calories, and in LIPOGAIN it was the saturated fat, not the seed oil, that added more fat to the liver.

It isn't a C, because the evidence on these points is not evenly split. It isn't an E, because a reader who comes away thinking "Americans eat a lot more oil than they used to, and it's mostly in fried and processed food" would be right. They would be wrong only about why that matters.


Nutrition Facts: Sources

  1. Robert F. Kennedy Jr on X, seed oils as "one of the driving causes of the obesi…
  2. Are seed oils unhealthy? Why are so many influencers speaking out against them?…
  3. Weedle on Bluesky, "WHY is it when you look back at people in the 70s they're S…
  4. Flingjore on Bluesky, sharing the Guardian seed-oil explainer (28 October 2026)
  5. NCHS Health E-Stat 111 — Prevalence of overweight, obesity, and severe obesity …
  6. USDA ERS Amber Waves — U.S. Food Consumption Up 16 Percent Since 1970 (Wells an…
  7. Blasbalg et al. (2011), AJCN — Changes in consumption of omega-3 and omega-6 fa…
  8. Flegal et al. (1995), NEJM — The influence of smoking cessation on the prevalen…
  9. Flegal (2007), AJPH — The effects of changes in smoking prevalence on obesity p…
  10. Hall et al. (2019), Cell Metabolism — Ultra-processed diets cause excess calori…
  11. Rosqvist et al. (2014), Diabetes — LIPOGAIN: overfeeding sunflower oil vs palm …
  12. Hooper et al. (2018), Cochrane — Omega-6 fats for the primary and secondary pre…
  13. Marklund et al. (2019), Circulation — Omega-6 biomarkers and incident cardiovas…
  14. Ramsden et al. (2016), BMJ — Re-evaluation of the Minnesota Coronary Experiment…
  15. 6 takeaways from RFK exclusive. No to flu shots, seed oils; yes to meat in diet…

Ingredients:
Fad Diets, Social Media Trends, seed oils, obesity, linoleic acid, omega-6, beef tallow, ultra-processed food

Analyzed and published by Nutribunk — an anonymous, reader-funded organization. No ads. No sponsors. No individual bylines.