Skip to main content
News · Original reporting

FDA's proposed GRAS rule would extend a low-dose exemption to ingredients added directly to food


Serving size
1 Report
Published
October 14, 2026

The rule that makes GRAS notification mandatory also lets intentionally added substances skip both a food-additive petition and GRAS notice under the threshold-of-regulation exemption, with FDA review that the agency itself calls abbreviated. Comments close 9 December.


On 11 August 2026 the FDA published a proposed rule titled "Substances Generally Recognized as Safe" (91 FR 51834, Docket FDA-2025-N-3262). Most of it makes GRAS notification mandatory. The same document also rewrites the "threshold of regulation" (TOR) exemption at 21 CFR 170.39, and that rewrite is what the past week's coverage has been about. The rule is a proposal, and comments are open until 9 December 2026.

What the exemption covers now

As the proposed rule describes current law (Section V.D), TOR applies only to substances in food-contact articles, such as packaging and processing equipment, that migrate into food. They must not have been shown to be carcinogens, and the resulting dietary concentration must be no more than 0.5 parts per billion, roughly 1.5 µg per person per day. The substance must also have "no technical effect in or on the food," which is what has limited TOR to incidental traces.

What the proposal changes

The proposed text says that "any substance used in food (both directly or indirectly added to food) will be exempted from regulation as a food additive or from the GRAS notification requirement under § 170.205, if it meets the TOR criteria." It removes the "no technical effect" requirement, so a functional ingredient added on purpose could qualify. A qualifying use would need neither a food-additive petition nor the new GRAS notice.

The changes, as written in the rule:

Provision Current Proposed
Scope Food-contact substances that migrate into food Substances "directly or indirectly added to food"
Technical effect Must have none Requirement removed
Exposure limit ≤0.5 ppb in the diet (≈1.5 µg/person/day) Estimated daily intake ≤0.025 µg/kg bodyweight/day
Carcinogenic impurities TD50 criterion of 6.25 mg/kg/day Lifetime cancer risk ≤1 in 1,000,000 at that intake, which FDA says the TD50 criterion equates to
Already-regulated direct additives New use adds ≤1% of the ADI Kept

FDA says the per-kilogram limit "normalizes exposure across subpopulations, ensuring an equivalent level of safety." Our own arithmetic on FDA's figures agrees: 1.5 µg a day divided by 60 kg is 0.025 µg/kg a day. The new number restates the old limit per kilogram. It does not raise the ceiling, and for a small child it is stricter in absolute terms.

The rule's only stated reasons for extending TOR to direct additives are "updated scientific guidance" and consistency with the GRAS program. The change is listed among the major provisions in the executive summary, but not in the one-sentence Summary at the top of the document.

Whether FDA reviews a request

Under the proposal, a TOR exemption is a request FDA decides on. It is not self-certification. Proposed § 170.39(c) requires a submission to include chemical identity, conditions of use, exposure data, "the results of an analysis of existing toxicological information on the substance and its impurities," and environmental information. Under § 170.39(b), FDA "may decline to grant an exemption in those cases in which available information establishes that the proposed use may pose a public health risk." Under § 170.39(f), FDA can re-evaluate an exemption and revoke it. Elsewhere in the rule, FDA calls TOR "an abbreviated review process."

The rule is also plain about how light that review is: "TOR submissions to FDA only require minimal data (e.g., identity, dietary exposure)… A full safety narrative is not required for a TOR submission." The criteria rest on exposure plus a carcinogen screen, and do not consider cumulative exposure from other sources. Under proposed § 170.39(e), FDA will keep a "publicly available list" of exempted substances and uses, without trade names. Exemptions will not be published in the Federal Register or the CFR.

FDA estimates 7 TOR requests a year for food substances, at about 48 hours of preparation each. That figure is borrowed from the existing food-contact TOR program, not estimated for direct additives. FDA puts the cost of the whole rule at a present value of about $89.6 million over ten years at 3%.

How it is being described

The current framing traces to a Guardian analysis by Tom Perkins published on 10 October. It said the rule may allow "toxic chemicals to be added to food without safety review," and gave flavorings, preservatives, emulsifiers, processing aids, enzymes, stabilizers and binders as examples of uses. That list is the Guardian's illustration; the rule's text says only "directly or indirectly added." Advocates quoted by the Guardian argued that perchlorate, some phthalates, bisphenols, PFAS and flame retardants are not carcinogens but could cause harm below 0.5 ppb, and so "could in theory" qualify. No specific substance has been proposed for TOR use under the new language. Maria Doa of the Environmental Defense Fund told the paper: "They're widening another loophole, but trying to say they made our food safer." Maricel Maffini, an independent consultant, said the low-dose premise "isn't supported by science of any kind."

The Guardian reported that HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and FDA's announcement materials did not mention the TOR change. We could not check this, because hhs.gov refused our requests. The Guardian also said it is unclear who added the TOR language. FDA did not respond to its request for comment.

On 12 October, Stand Up for Science! posted a four-post Bluesky thread saying the FDA would let "big food" add "toxic chemicals directly to food without a safety review." The New American's summary the same day describes the rule accurately and draws on the Guardian for the rest.

The phrase "without a safety review" does not match the rule as written, which requires a request that FDA grants or declines. The coverage's point that the review is abbreviated, needs minimal data and requires no full safety narrative is in the rule's own words.

The perchlorate precedent

Advocates point to perchlorate. FDA's 2017 Federal Register notice (82 FR 20847) denied in full a petition from NRDC, EWG, CSPI and others to revoke TOR exemption No. 2005-006. That exemption covers sodium perchlorate monohydrate in antistatic agents. FDA's migration study estimated adult exposure at 0.075 µg per person per day. FDA's Q&A page says perchlorate remains permitted up to 1.2% by weight of finished polymer for dry-food contact; a separate gasket use was revoked effective 4 May 2017.

The Guardian reports that FDA data showed perchlorate in children's cereal "dramatically increased" after the exemption. We could not find that figure in the FDA sources we read. FDA's perchlorate page says its 2008–2012 Total Diet Study found "no overall change in perchlorate levels across foods" compared with 2005–2006, and does not break out cereal. The 2017 notice does not discuss the Total Diet Study. We are not reporting the outcome of the perchlorate litigation, because we did not read the ruling.

Context

The GRAS half of the rule was promoted as closing a loophole. The Environmental Working Group, an advocacy organization, counts at least 111 food chemicals self-declared GRAS without notifying FDA, and notes that being on its list "does not mean a substance is harmful." Even the new GRAS requirement is not premarket approval: firms could still market a substance before FDA finishes reviewing its notice.

Removing the words "no technical effect" is what extends the exemption from packaging traces to ingredients added on purpose. Readers who want FDA to keep, narrow or drop that change have until 9 December to say so in Docket FDA-2025-N-3262.


Nutrition Facts: Sources

  1. FDA proposed rule — Substances Generally Recognized as Safe, 91 FR 51834 (11 Au…
  2. The Guardian (Tom Perkins, analysis) — FDA may allow some toxic chemicals to be…
  3. The New American (Veronika Kyrylenko) — FDA Proposes Expanding Food Chemical Ex…
  4. Stand Up for Science! — Bluesky thread on the TOR expansion (12 Oct 2026)
  5. FDA — NRDC et al.; Denial of Food Additive Petition (perchlorate TOR exemption …
  6. FDA — Perchlorate in food (Total Diet Study summary)
  7. FDA — Perchlorate: Questions and Answers
  8. EWG — Secret GRAS: How 100+ food chemicals bypassed government safety review

Ingredients:
Food Safety, fda, gras, food additives, threshold of regulation, perchlorate, proposed rules

Reported and published by Nutribunk — an anonymous, reader-funded organization. No ads. No sponsors. No individual bylines.