Skip to main content
News · Repackaged · with commentary

FOX 17's ultra-processed food story is more careful than its headline


Serving size
1 Reshare + commentary
Published
October 14, 2026

Repackaged from: FOX 17 News (WZTV Nashville)
A new analysis of nearly 8.8 million adults found that people who reported eating more foods classified as ultra-processed also tended to have higher rates of several chronic health conditions and death over time.

Read the original at FOX 17 News (WZTV Nashville) →

The excerpt above is FOX 17 News (WZTV Nashville)’s original reporting, quoted under fair use. Everything below the heavy rule is Nutribunk’s own commentary.


Our commentary

What FOX 17 reported, and what it got right

FOX 17 News in Nashville, in a piece by Ashley Griffin, covered a new meta-analysis in Family Medicine and Community Health, a BMJ Group journal, that pooled 51 prospective cohort studies. As FOX 17 reports it, the adults with the highest reported intake of ultra-processed food had higher relative rates of cardiovascular events, cancer, obesity, metabolic syndrome or diabetes, depression or anxiety, digestive diseases and death than those with the lowest intake. Its example figures were 24% for cardiovascular events and 18% for all-cause death, plus increments per extra 100 g a day. We checked these against the paper and they match.

We're sharing it because the body of the article is a careful example of how to report nutritional epidemiology. In its second paragraph FOX 17 says the study does not prove ultra-processed foods caused the outcomes. It explains that the percentages "are not a person's chance of getting sick or dying". It notes that the NOVA classification puts nutritionally very different foods in one bucket, that the diet data was self-reported, that income, smoking, activity and other factors could explain part of the link, and that the authors rated their own certainty as low for most outcomes. Many national outlets leave those points out.

Where it slips

The headline is "Daily junk food intake linked to higher chronic disease risk in new major study". The paper isn't about junk food. It is about NOVA-classified ultra-processed food, and the authors' own examples of that category include wholegrain bread and unsweetened yoghurt. FOX 17's body text is more careful, calling these foods "often described as 'junk' food". But many readers only see the headline.

One sentence also says independent experts reviewed the research for the Science Media Centre. We could not find any Science Media Centre reaction to this paper, so we treat that line as unverified.

Three things the coverage left out

The 8.8 million figure is real, but most of it comes from one outcome. Individual studies ranged from 896 to 5,468,444 participants. The digestive-disease analysis alone covers 6,073,960 people across six cohorts. The cardiovascular figure FOX 17 led with comes from 441,175 people in 12 cohorts, and the mortality figure from about 400,000 in nine. None of the headline percentages rests on 8.8 million people.

Adjustment for confounders was thin. The authors write: "Age was the most commonly adjusted confounder, whereas adjustment for other confounders varied across studies." That is a stronger reason for caution than the general list of confounders FOX 17 gives. The results also varied a lot between studies (I² of 74% for cardiovascular events and cancer, 94% for metabolic syndrome or diabetes). The authors say the pooled figures "should be interpreted as average associations ... rather than as uniform effect sizes". No outcome had enough studies to test for publication bias.

Blood pressure was a null result in the main comparison. For hypertension, the highest-versus-lowest hazard ratio was 1.09 with a confidence interval of 0.99 to 1.20, which includes no effect. The 11% increase per 100 g a day comes from the separate dose-response analysis, and the authors rated the hypertension evidence very low certainty. FOX 17 didn't make much of hypertension. The BMJ Group press release did: its lead names high blood pressure among the linked conditions with no caveat.

What the study does support

"Higher ultra-processed food intake is linked to higher rates of chronic disease" is a fair one-line summary. The direction is the same across seven outcome groups, and the confidence intervals exclude no effect for all of them except hypertension. What the study cannot support is the causal reading or the "junk food" framing. The paper reports no absolute risks. It cites research linking chocolate and nuts, both of which can count as ultra-processed, to lower risk, and the authors argue that grouping such foods together may hide the harms of worse subtypes. They also argue that measurement error probably pushes the results toward no effect. That is their argument, not something the paper shows. Neither the paper nor FOX 17 claims a safe level of intake has been established.

"A new major study" is rarely just one

Two other links we received about this story covered entirely different research. The Globe and Mail's Leslie Beck rounded up a UK Biobank analysis presented at a diabetes conference, a four-week pilot trial in 20 adults with depression, and a review of proposed brain mechanisms. Medical News Today covered a small Virginia Tech feeding study. It compared one pair of nutrient-matched meals in young, healthy adults and found a higher insulin response after the ultra-processed meal. MNT notes this did not show the response was harmful. When three different designs all circulate as "the ultra-processed food study", the details get lost. FOX 17's body copy keeps them. Read past the headline.


Nutrition Facts: Sources

  1. FOX 17 (WZTV), Ashley Griffin — Daily junk food intake linked to higher chronic…
  2. Liu et al. (2026), Family Medicine and Community Health — Ultra-processed food …
  3. BMJ Group press release — Higher UPF intake linked to heightened risk of multip…
  4. The Globe and Mail, Leslie Beck — More reasons to ditch ultraprocessed foods (1…
  5. Medical News Today, Erika Watts — Even when nutrient-dense, ultra-processed foo…

Ingredients:
Nutrition Research, ultra-processed food, nova classification, meta-analysis, observational studies, diet studies

Commentary by Nutribunk — an anonymous, reader-funded organization. Original reporting credited above. No ads. No sponsors. No individual bylines.