On 16 November 2026, the precision-fermentation start-up New Culture said on its company blog that the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) had approved three things for its animal-free mozzarella. They were the production process, a "new, CDFA-approved commercial facility in the Bay Area", and the product label. According to the company, the approved product name is "Mozzarella Style Animal-free Dairy Cheese", and the ingredient is listed as "Animal-free casein (from fermentation)".
New Culture calls this "the world's first-ever production permit for animal-free dairy mozzarella." That is the company's claim, and no source Nutribunk reviewed verifies it independently. More broadly, everything known about the approval comes from New Culture. Nutribunk found no CDFA statement, document or permit number about it, and none of the trade coverage (FoodNavigator, Green Queen, vegconomist) cited one either.
It is a state approval to make and label the product in California. It is not an FDA approval.
What the company says the review covered
New Culture's post describes a process in which it first produces casein by fermentation and then makes cheese from it in a way that "mimics the conventional approach for low-moisture mozzarella". The company says it "could follow CDFA's standard approval process for cheesemaking", but had to supply "several rounds of detailed information".
According to the post, the review covered critical control points, cooling, packaging and equipment sterilisation, as well as supplier verification, chain of custody, and storage at room temperature, frozen and refrigerated. The company says CDFA "requires dairy alternatives to uphold the same rigorous standard of facility design and sanitation as … animal-derived dairy", and that it had to make "minor upgrades" so the walls could be cleaned.
The post gives no permit number, no licence type, no launch date and no price. vegconomist likewise reported that the company "has not given a launch date or pricing."
What California's rules provide
CDFA's public pages do not list anything called a "production permit". What they do list is a Products Resembling Milk Products (PRMP) Plant License, required to process and package products that look, taste, smell, feel or are coloured like a milk product, or that could substitute for one. The examples CDFA gives include "substitute cheeses". The department says a PRMP plant "must meet the same sanitation requirements as a milk products plant", and each product must also be registered.
The California Food and Agricultural Code makes it unlawful to manufacture such products without a current-year licence for each plant (§38931). It requires manufacturers to register their products (§38941), and sets health and purity standards that "shall not be less than those of the milk products imitated or substituted" (§38924). Under CDFA's label review rules, labels for milk products, cheeses and PRMPs must be submitted for approval before they are used. That explains why a state agency had a say in the product's name.
Given that framework, New Culture's approval is most likely a PRMP plant licence plus product registration and label approval. That is an inference. Neither the company nor any outlet has named the licence type, and CDFA has not said. What the framework does show is that the company's description of dairy-equivalent sanitation standards is accurate. California law requires it.
What federal status the casein has
The novel ingredient here is the casein, and its safety status is a separate matter from California's plant and label rules. In early 2024 New Culture said its animal-free casein was Generally Recognized As Safe, after a review by an independent panel of scientific and toxicology experts, FoodNavigator reported at the time. This was a self-affirmed GRAS determination, made by the company, not by FDA. The same article said New Culture would seek a "no questions" letter from FDA, which CEO Matt Gibson described as "an extra green light from the federal government".
As of this week, FoodNavigator reports the casein "has not yet received a 'no questions' letter from FDA". Asked by Green Queen whether the company plans to notify FDA, co-founder Inja Radman "has no updates". Nutribunk checked the 50 most recent entries in FDA's GRAS Notice Inventory (last updated 2 November 2026) and found no New Culture notice among them. The full inventory of 1,360 records was not searched, so whether New Culture has ever filed a notice could not be established.
vegconomist's report says the company "now holds that federal ingredient status alongside the state product approvals". That is wrong. A self-affirmed GRAS determination is the company's own conclusion. It is not a status FDA confers.
The self-affirmation route itself may be closing. In an August 2026 proposed rule, FDA proposes to "convert the voluntary GRAS notification program to a mandatory" one, with "a time-limited option to make a streamlined submission" for some substances already in interstate commerce. Comments are due 9 December 2026. The rule is a proposal, not law, and Nutribunk has not established how long the streamlined window would run.
"Animal-free" is not "milk-free" for allergies
The 2024 FoodNavigator report described New Culture's casein as "bioidentical" to dairy casein, and said people with a milk-protein allergy cannot eat it. Casein is a milk allergen. None of this week's coverage that Nutribunk reviewed mentions this.
New Culture's post says labels must carry "relevant allergen statements", but it does not say what allergen statement the approved label carries, and Nutribunk could not establish it. Earlier company material relayed by Cultivated X in January 2025 described the cheese as free of soy, nuts, gluten, lactose and cholesterol. A "free of" list like that is not an allergen-free claim. The product contains the milk protein itself.
Timeline
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Feb–Mar 2024 | New Culture self-affirms GRAS status for its casein | vegconomist; FoodNavigator (2024) |
| Apr 2024 | CDFA application submitted, per Radman | Green Queen |
| Jan 2025 | Label and registration submitted to CDFA | Cultivated X; vegconomist |
| Mar 2025 | Company still "awaiting regulatory approval from" CDFA | Cultivated X |
| 11 Aug 2026 | FDA proposes mandatory GRAS notification | Federal Register |
| 16 Nov 2026 | New Culture announces CDFA approvals | New Culture |
| 9 Dec 2026 | Comment deadline on FDA proposal | Federal Register |
The April 2024 and January 2025 dates may refer to two separate filings. The sources do not settle it.
What isn't known
Radman told FoodNavigator that "our first channel is foodservice, particularly pizzerias", and that the company will "begin with California before eventually growing to other markets." FoodNavigator also said New Culture "already supplies its mozzarella" to Nancy Silverton's Pizzeria Mozza, but gave no source. In January 2025, Cultivated X said the restaurant would serve the cheese "once approved", and Radman "did not specifically address" the partnership when Green Queen asked. Whether the cheese is served anywhere yet could not be established.
California has done what its law asks of a dairy look-alike: inspected the plant against dairy sanitation standards and approved the label before use. The question of whether the novel protein is safe has, so far, been answered only through the company's own GRAS determination. FDA's proposed rule would change that, but it is not final.